Screenwriting · Leçon 1

Premise, Logline and the Dramatic Question

Vous saurez

  • Distinguish an idea, a premise and a logline, and turn one into the next
  • Formulate the dramatic question that keeps an audience watching to the end
  • Test a premise for conflict, stakes and a visible goal before writing a single page

45 min · Votre progression est enregistrée uniquement sur cet appareil.

Leçon 1/3

Most unfinished screenplays don't fail on page 60. They fail before page 1. The writer starts with an image, a mood, a setting or a character they like, writes twenty pages, and then finds there is nothing to drive the next ninety. This lesson is about the work you do before writing scenes. It costs about an hour, and it saves months.

Idea, premise, logline

An idea is raw material: "a scholar who has read everything and is still unhappy"; "a city under foreign occupation"; "a knight who refuses to bow." Ideas are cheap and plentiful. They hold no conflict yet.

A premise is an idea with a dramatic engine: a specific character wants something specific, and something specific stands in the way, and the outcome matters. The premise answers four questions:

  1. Who? One protagonist, defined by a trait that matters to the story.
  2. Wants what? A goal that can be seen on screen. "Happiness" is not visible. "Win the election," "get the girl out of prison" and "reach Rome" are.
  3. Against what? An opposing force: an antagonist, an institution, nature, or the protagonist's own flaw. This is ideally personified, because film shows people.
  4. At what cost? The stakes. What is lost if the protagonist fails?

A logline is the premise compressed into one sentence of 25–40 words, written to make a reader want the script. A common working template:

When [inciting incident], a [flawed protagonist] must [goal] before/or else [stakes], but [central obstacle or irony].

Templates are scaffolding. Use them to check that all the parts are present, then rewrite the sentence until it sounds like a person talking.

The dramatic question

Every feature film poses one central question early, usually by the end of the first act, and answers it in the climax: Will she get out? Will he win the case? Will they stay together? This dramatic question is the promise you make to the audience. Subplots raise smaller questions. The audience will tolerate digression, slow passages and even confusion as long as the main question is open and they care about the answer.

Two rules follow:

  • Pose it clearly. If the audience doesn't know what the protagonist is trying to do, they can't worry about whether it will happen.
  • Answer it. The answer can be yes, no, or "yes, but at a terrible price." It can also be a reframing, where the protagonist gets something other than what they wanted and it turns out to be what they needed. What you can't do is forget the question.

The wager as a model premise

Goethe's Faust I (1808) is a play of nearly 4,600 lines, but its premise can be stated in one sentence because Goethe puts it on stage before the story starts. In the "Prolog im Himmel," Mephistopheles bets the Lord that he can lead the scholar Faust away from his source and down his own road. The Lord allows it for as long as Faust lives on earth. Before Faust appears, the audience already knows:

  • the protagonist (Faust, a restless striver),
  • the antagonist (Mephistopheles, who wants to win him),
  • the stakes (Faust's soul and, at a higher level, whether human striving is worth anything),
  • the dramatic question: Will Mephistopheles corrupt Faust?

This is a frame premise, a contract signed above the characters' heads. Film uses the same device constantly: a prologue, a cold open or a voice-over shows the audience the bet, the deadline or the bomb under the table. Hitchcock described the difference between surprise and suspense in exactly these terms. If the audience knows what the characters don't, every ordinary scene gets tension.

Leçon 2/3

Testing a premise

Before you outline, run your premise through these tests:

  1. The active verb test. Is the protagonist's goal a verb the camera can film (escape, steal, win, rescue, find, expose)? "Come to terms with" and "learn to accept" are needs. They belong underneath a filmable goal, not in place of one.
  2. The opposition test. Is the opposing force at least as strong as the protagonist? If the obstacle is weak, there is no story.
  3. The stakes test. Ask "so what?" three times. If the answer is still abstract after the third time, raise the stakes or make them personal.
  4. The irony test. The strongest premises contain an irony: the protagonist's goal or flaw works against itself. Faust wants to experience everything. The one thing he really experiences is love, and his pursuit of it destroys the woman he loves.
  5. The ending test. Can you imagine at least two possible answers to the dramatic question? If only one ending is possible, the audience will feel it and lose interest.
  6. The "why now?" test. Why does the story start today and not last year? Something has to change: an inciting incident that forces action.

Genre is a promise too

Your premise also signals genre, and genre is a set of expectations about tone, pace and ending. A thriller logline promises danger and a ticking clock. A romantic comedy logline promises two incompatible people and a reason they must keep meeting. Decide your genre early, not to follow formula but to know which expectations you are fulfilling and which you are deliberately breaking. Faust I starts as a philosophical drama, turns into a seduction comedy and ends as a tragedy. Goethe can afford that because the frame premise holds it together. A first screenplay usually can't.

Format note for this course

Throughout the course you write in Goethe Write, which has a screenplay layout (scene headings, action, character, dialogue, parenthetical, transition). You won't need the format in this lesson; you are working in the outline and notes. Format is lesson 07.

From premise to page count

A feature screenplay runs about 90–120 pages, roughly a minute of screen time per page. A one-hour drama pilot runs 50–65 pages, a half-hour comedy 25–35. Your premise has to carry that length. As a rough check: a premise for a feature should produce at least three different sequences of escalating obstacles when you brainstorm it. If you can only think of one obstacle, you have a short film. That is a perfectly good form, and the final project allows it.

Common mistakes

  • The situation without a protagonist ("a world where water is rationed"). Whose story is it?
  • The passive protagonist who lets things happen. Characters may be reluctant at first, but by the end of act one they have to choose.
  • The private goal, where nobody else can see whether the protagonist is winning or losing.
  • Too many protagonists. Ensemble films exist, but each of their storylines needs its own premise.
  • The theme instead of a story ("a film about grief"). Theme comes out of the story. It doesn't replace one.

Leçon 3/3

Worked example: from idea to logline in four steps

Idea: "a night guard in a museum."
Step 1, protagonist with a trait: a night guard who has worked in the same museum for thirty years and knows every creak of the floor.
Step 2, visible goal: he must catch the thief who is replacing paintings with forgeries, one a week.
Step 3, opposition: the thief is the new director, who has the keys, the cameras and the board's trust.
Step 4, stakes and irony: if he fails, he is blamed and loses his pension; and the only proof he has is that the forgeries "sound wrong" on his rounds, which no one will believe.

Logline: "When paintings in a provincial museum are secretly swapped for forgeries, a night guard nobody listens to must expose the new director before the board blames him, armed with nothing but thirty years of knowing how the building sounds."

Look at what each step added. The trait (knowing the building) becomes the protagonist's only weapon, so character and plot are linked from the first sentence. The antagonist controls the institutions, so the opposition is strong. The irony is that the most overlooked person in the building is the only one who notices. You can also see the dramatic question immediately (will he expose the director?) and both possible answers.

Chez Goethe

Chez Goethe

1. The wager: Faust. Eine Tragödie (1808), "Prolog im Himmel"

Mephistopheles: Was wettet ihr? den sollt ihr noch verlieren!
Wenn ihr mir die Erlaubniß gebt
Ihn meine Straße sacht zu führen.
Der Herr: So lang' er auf der Erde lebt,
So lange sey dir's nicht verboten.
Es irrt der Mensch so lang er strebt.

Translation: MEPHISTOPHELES: What will you bet? You'll lose him yet, if you give me leave to lead him gently down my road. — THE LORD: As long as he lives on earth, so long it is not forbidden you. Man errs as long as he strives.

Analysis: In six lines Goethe states the antagonist's goal ("lead him down my road"), the method ("gently"), the time limit ("as long as he lives on earth") and the theme ("man errs as long as he strives"). The dramatic question is stated outright as a bet, the most concrete form a question can take. Notice that the Lord does not deny the risk. A premise works only if failure is really possible.

Lire le texte intégral sur goethecloud.com →

2. The deadline: Faust I, "Straße"

Faust: Und das sag' ich ihm kurz und gut,
Wenn nicht das süße junge Blut
Heut' Nacht in meinen Armen ruht;
So sind wir um Mitternacht geschieden.

Translation: And I tell you short and plain: if that sweet young thing does not lie in my arms tonight, then at midnight you and I are through.

Analysis: Inside the large frame question Goethe sets up a smaller, sharper one with a ticking clock ("tonight," "at midnight"). Subplot questions with deadlines keep the middle of a story moving. The line also characterises Faust: impatient, used to getting what he wants, morally careless. Goethe builds the premise and the flaw at the same time.

Source: goethecloud.com, Goethe library, Faust I, first edition Tübingen: Cotta, 1808.

Lire le texte intégral sur goethecloud.com →

Source: Goethe library on goethecloud.com. Public domain.

Dans Goethe Write

Dans Goethe Write

  1. Create the project. New project → type Screenplay. Name it with a working title; you can rename later.
  2. Write the premise in Notes. Open Notes and create a note called Premise. Write four headed lines: Who / Wants / Against / Stakes. Keep it to four sentences.
  3. Draft loglines as versions. Create a note Logline. Write your first version, then use Versions → Save version before each rewrite. By the end you should have at least five saved versions, and you can compare any two side by side to see what each rewrite gained or lost.
  4. Pin the dramatic question. Put the dramatic question as the first line of the Outline, so it sits above every scene you will add later. Each time you open the outline, it reminds you what the scenes are for.
  5. Ask Goethe for a stress test (optional, with your own API key). Select your premise note and ask the assistant: "Apply the six premise tests from this lesson. For each, say pass or fail and why in one sentence. Do not rewrite my premise." Use the answer as a checklist, not as a replacement for your judgement.
  6. Export. Export → PDF of the note gives you a one-page premise sheet for the final project.

Exercice 1/5

Idea to premise

Exercice 2/5

Five loglines

Exercice 3/5

Frame premise

Exercice 4/5

Premise audit

Exercice 5/5

Two endings

Liste de contrôle

Liste de contrôle

Cochez chaque point quand il est vrai pour votre texte.

Leçon terminée

Leçon terminée

Bravo. Votre résultat est enregistré sur cet appareil.

Leçon suivanteRetour au cours